Are you considering a new roof but unsure whether to choose stone-coated steel or GAF TimberSteel shingles?
Are you hoping to have the durability of a metal roof with a more classic shingle look?
Metal shingles are a major talking point right now! And they’re making a pretty big impact.
This is largely in part due to North America’s largest shingle manufacturer, GAF, releasing their own kind of metal shingles. And as GAF Master Elite contractors it may seem like we have a bias, but we think it’s important to educate you to make the right decision so you can be satisfied with whatever you choose!
In this article, we’ll explore the benefits and drawbacks of stone coated and TimberSteel metal shingles to help you make the best decision for your home. We’ll cover everything from cost, longevity, and maintenance requirements so you can compare each type according to what you’re looking for!
Now let’s take a look at what metal shingles can offer you!
A Comparison of Stone Coated Steel vs. TimberSteel Metal Shingles
Comparing metal shingles is not as difficult as it may seem. When it comes to stone coated steel and TimberSteel shingles, you may be curious to know the main differences so you can make a decision that’s best for you. Below you’ll find a chart that outlines the main differences between stone coated steel and TimberSteel metal shingles, including cost, longevity, the benefits, and the downsides of each metal shingle type.
|
Category |
Stone Coated Steel Shingles |
GAF TimberSteel Metal Shingles |
|
Cost |
$36,000 - $60,000 for a 30-square roof |
$18,000 - $51,000 for a 30-square roof |
|
Longevity |
15 - 20 years |
25 - 50 years |
|
Benefits |
|
|
|
Downsides |
|
|
You may find yourself asking “If they’re both metal shingles, why do they seem so different?”
One reason is that stone coated metal shingles are the original kind of metal shingle. Meaning that newer versions, like TimberSteel, may have been able to draw off of current needs and trends we see today. But that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re better than the original stone coated steel shingles.
With that said, it’s only fair to look at the benefits of both of these metal shingles.
What are the Benefits of Choosing Metal Shingles: Stone Coated Steel vs. TimberSteel
Metal shingles are a great option for homeowners who want the benefits of a metal roof without the metal roof look. Often when homeowners are looking into metal roofing shingles, their top priority is having a durable roof installed on their home so they can feel well protected. So as you proceed, be sure to educate yourself on the average lifespan of other roofing materials so you can compare wisely!
Let’s start by uncovering the main benefits of stone coated metal roofing shingles.
The Benefits of Stone Coated Metal Roofing Shingles
Stone coated shingles are the original form of metal roofing shingles. As the name suggests, they’re made of steel panels that are coated with rock granules. While they look like shingles, they have the durability of a traditional metal roof. Thus combining the durability of a metal roof with a more classic and traditional look.
The Benefits of TimberSteel Metal Roofing Shingles
TimberSteel metal shingles are GAF’s newest addition in their line up of high quality roofing materials. TimberSteel tends to have a more reasonable price point than their predecessor, stone coated shingles. These metal shingles offer a modern look, differing from the look of both metal roofs and traditional asphalt shingles. Which can be a great option for homeowners who want something different from what we’ve always seen in the past.
But you may be wondering.. what are the downsides to these metal shingles?
What are the Downsides of Choosing Metal Shingles: Stone Coated Steel vs. TimberSteel
While metal shingles are a great option for longevity and durability, it would be misleading to say they don’t have any flaws. For the most part, metal shingles outperform your regular asphalt shingles, but they’re not without faults of their own.
The Downside of Stone Coated Steel Roofing Shingles
If you decide to go with the more traditional metal shingle route, it’s important to mention that stone coated steel shingles will cost more than some traditional metal roofs and TimberSteel. Not only that, but stone coated metal shingles need more maintenance over time. This is because steel coated shingles are attached to your roof with screws that can deteriorate over time. So, it’s important to have regular maintenance visits if you choose a steel coated shingle for your home.
The Downside of TimberSteel Shingles
One of the more obvious downsides of TimberSteel shingles is its appearance. These shingles don’t look like your average asphalt shingle and they don’t look like a metal roof. In short, they have a very modern aesthetic, which is great if you’re trying to achieve a modern look for your home. On the other hand, this metal shingle may clash with your home’s current exterior design.
Deciding if Metal Shingles are Right for You
Deciding between stone coated steel and GAF TimberSteel can seem like a daunting task, unless you’re a roofing expert. Which is why we decided to break down the benefits and the downsides of both types for you. And while we wouldn’t insert ourselves into your final decision, we’re happy to provide you with the straightforward information you need to make an informed decision.
Ultimately, this choice comes down to preference. If cost is a major concern, TimberSteel might be a better option. On the other hand, if you prefer the look of traditional asphalt shingles, stone coated steel may be the right option for you. But if you’re still unsure, it may benefit you to look into the cost of a metal roof, the benefits, and the problems associated with metal roofs. Not only that, but you may also be curious to learn more about the roof replacement process.
When it comes to transparent information about roofing materials, we at Linta Roofing are proud to be your #1 source of information. Whether you need help choosing the right material or you’re ready for an estimate, we are here to help!